Driscoll and Mahaney

By | March 27, 2014

It appears Brent Detwiler is prescient.  One year ago he authored an article titled “The Twin Brothers Driscoll and Mahaney.”  I suggest you go directly to Detwiler’s blog and read the article, but in lieu of that, Detwiler has given me permission to quote liberally from his post, which I do below.  It makes for some timely reading.


Screenshot 2014-03-27 09.17.53

…Like with C.J., Mark intimidated his local elders.  Like with C.J., the elders showed Mark favoritism, craved his approval, and allowed him to play by a different set of rules.  Like with C.J., an employee could easily lose their job or be demoted if you confronted or offended Mark.  Like with C.J., Mark set up a puppet board and changed the bylaws (used the bylaws in C.J.’s case) to secure his power.  Like with C.J., you could be excommunicated or shunned if you didn’t comply with authoritarian demands.  These boys are birds of a feather.

… C.J. last told me about his interactions with Mark Driscoll in November 2007 during my last leadership team retreat when I resigned from the Board of Directors for Sovereign Grace Ministries after 25 years (see A Final Appeal, pp. 90-92).  C.J. informed us then that Mark had asked for his input. This was another classic illustration of C.J.’s hypocrisy.  He was going to help Mark  discern the presence of pride in his life even though C.J. rejected all our attempts to help him see the fruits of pride in his own life.  He was going to cultivate humility in Mark’s heart when he refused to let others cultivate humility in his own heart.  I distinctly remember sitting in the meeting with Dave Harvey, Steve Shank and Pat Ennis stunned by the irony and audacity

…In reality, this person would act as a substitute for the elders in his “unique role.”  That is so often the problem.  There is no true plurality of leadership.  The founder, President, or senior pastor is functionally unaccountable.  The elders are afraid to be honest and fear losing their jobs.  For instance, they will not confront such men for neglecting their wives and children as they pour 70-80 hours into their ministries each week.

…C.J.’s involvement didn’t produce changes in Mark’s life.  C.J. may have provided “care, counsel and correction” but it didn’t translate into repentance, confession or restitution.  Like twins, Mark and C.J. responses to correction were identical.  Little fruit and no concern for people like Paul and Jonna Petry who were figuratively left to die in a roadside ravine after being blindsided by a Mack Truck.

…In the same way, C.J.‘s sins were covered up, so too were Mark’s.  The scenario at Mars Hills Church with Mark is almost identical to our dealings with C.J. in Sovereign Grace Ministries.  Like C.J., Mark took control of the process.  Like C.J., he silenced dissent.  Like C.J., he removed people he didn’t like any longer because they challenged him.   Like C.J., he surrounded himself with devotees.

…Nationally recognized leaders know there are serious issues with C.J. and Mark but  will not risk their own reputations, ministries or revenue streams in order to address them or don’t want to draw attention to themselves realizing they suffer from the same maladies.  In the former case, they fear losing favor (i.e., national recognition) over a falling out with Driscoll or Mahaney or whomever.  You don’t get invitations to speak at Conferences, preach at churches, teach in seminaries, sign book deals or benefit from name recognition by offending the powerful.  Young men like David Platt, Kevin DeYoung, and Matt Chandler are not going to correct or challenge Dever, Duncan, Mahaney or Mohler.

As a result, guys like C.J. and Mark fly beneath the radar screen undetected.  Inside their organizations, people are afraid to speak up for fear of consequences.  Outside their organizations, peers withhold critique in order to secure their favor and avoid offense.  Instead they build alliances of mutual benefit which are a key to advancing and promoting their ministries.  A lot of money, growth, and recognition comes in the aftermath.  On those occasions when conflicts arise, they are concealed and truces are secured.

Furthermore, if one of them is exposed from within or without their organizations, these alliances defend against attacks and silence the opposition.  As a result, people like the Petry’s are oppressed, mistreated, and forgotten like Old Testament widows, orphans or sojourners in distress.  They receive no help, no protection, and no care.  While nationally known leaders should be addressing Driscoll (or C.J.) the work is left to the weak, broken, and despised.


Submit Comment

newest oldest
Notify of

Oh and James MacDonald, of course, now serves on Mark Driscoll’s BOAA….


Matthew 15:14
“Let them alone; they are blind guides. And if the blind lead the blind, both will fall into a pit.”


Sadly, the same DNA discussed above also appears to be identical to that of James MacDonald (et al) at Harvest Bible Chapel. See theelephantsdebt.com.

He blew up the board to centralize power and then the cover ups, the pride, countless people coming forward of how their lives were destroyed, the gambling, the abuse, the power, the debt, lying about all of it, developed a persecution complex as a cover for his wrong doing, never accepting responsibility for what happened…on and on it goes. He ended up blaming all of it on “attacks outside the church”. Elders left, leaders left, pastors left, churches left the fellowship…Awful.

It absolutely amazes me what is happening to the Church…It’s been 18 months since I left Harvest leadership, and I am still trying to sort through what it all means. The impact of leaders in our churches continuing to serve after clear disqualification is so damaging in so many different ways.

And to watch Gospel Coalition continuing to support guys like Driscoll is beyond comprehension. End times indeed.

Thanks for your comment John. I am sorry to hear that you have been through some tough times at Harvest, but I am confident that in time you will be a stronger “oak tree’ in the Kingdom.

While sad to see the damage these wolves are causing amongst the sheep it does appear our Lord Jesus Christ is moving to rid the Church of their influence. We can take confidence in the following:

“He said to them, “But who do you say that I am?” Simon Peter replied, “You are the Christ, the Son of the living God.” And Jesus answered him, “Blessed are you, Simon Bar-Jonah! For flesh and blood has not revealed this to you, but my Father who is in heaven. And I tell you, you are Peter, and on this rock I will build my church, and the gates of hell shall not prevail against it.”
Matthew 16:15-18